Open Wall Panels vs. Structural Insulated Panels (SIPs): Jobsite Staging, Subcontractor Vetting & Material Bid Audits

Open Wall Panels vs. Structural Insulated Panels (SIPs): Jobsite Staging, Subcontractor Vetting & Material Bid Audits

Show Notes:

Learn the practical engineering, framing, and inspection differences between factory-built open wall panels and closed structural insulated panels (SIPs) for custom residential construction. We examine why open 2×6 wall framing panels align seamlessly with conventional trade tools, municipal rough-in inspections, and local subcontractor workflows without requiring specialized lifting equipment. Discover how just-in-time flatbed delivery staging coordinates directly with foundation backfill completion so framing crews erect wall bundles immediately upon unloading, minimizing weather exposure and on-site storage risks. We outline a realistic framework for owner-builders to decide which finishes to self-perform versus hiring licensed trade specialists, alongside practical strategies for vetting reliable subcontractors through municipal plan checkers and material supply houses. Explore our prefab vs modular home comparison to understand structural framing advantages, and learn how to audit competing lumber bids to ensure your panelized building kits include complete interior walls, engineered beams, and stamped permit plans.

Key Q&A Highlights from Episode 106

Q: What is the structural and framing difference between open wall panels and closed structural insulated panels (SIPs)?

A: Open wall panels are built with conventional 2×6 dimensional lumber spaced 16 inches on center with exterior OSB sheathing, allowing framers, electricians, and plumbers to use standard tools and follow familiar rough-in inspection routines. Closed structural insulated panels (SIPs) sandwich foam cores between two OSB skins, which requires specialized engineering, custom electrical chases, and niche installation crews that are often harder to source locally.

Q: How does just-in-time flatbed delivery protect panelized wall bundles from weather and jobsite damage?

A: Rather than dropping materials onto an unready lot weeks ahead of schedule, deliveries are timed directly after foundation backfill and curing are complete. Bundles of six to ten wall panels and banded roof trusses are staged in assembly sequence so framing crews unload the flatbed and immediately erect the structural shell, minimizing exposure to rain, theft, and ground moisture.

Q: How can first-time owner-builders find and vet reliable specialty trade subcontractors?

A: Owner-builders can source vetted trades by asking trusted excavation or foundation contractors for downstream referrals, consulting local roofing or lumber supply houses, and asking municipal building department staff which contractors consistently pass inspections. Presenting trades with a complete, detailed set of architectural and structural blueprints also signals project readiness and encourages competitive, accurate bidding.

Q: Which construction tasks should owner-builders hire out rather than attempting to DIY?

A: Unless an owner-builder has verified professional trade experience, complex structural and finish tasks—such as foundation concrete, electrical wiring, plumbing, and drywall taping and mudding—should be hired out to licensed specialists. Attempting technical trade work based solely on online tutorials frequently leads to failed municipal inspections and costly remediation repairs that exceed original subcontractor quotes.

Q: How do you accurately compare competing quotes from different panelized kit home suppliers?

A: Lowball panel quotes often price only exterior wall shells while omitting interior partition framing, floor joist systems, roof trusses, structural beams, sheathing, and state-stamped engineering plans. Auditing quotes line-by-line ensures you are comparing a complete, locked-in structural package rather than an incomplete partial lumber drop that requires expensive local re-engineering.

Transcript:

Steve Tuma: People email us a plan, or they’ll pick a plan off our website, or they’ll sketch it on a napkin and text it to us, and we can go through and get them a price in a day or two.

Host: How you doing, everybody, and welcome to episode 106 of the Panelized Prefab Kit Home Building Show. With me today, as he usually is, is the president and founder of Landmark Home and Land Company, a company which has been helping people build their new homes where they want, exactly as they want, nationwide and around the globe since 1993, Mr. Steve Tuma. Steve, how you doing, buddy?

Steve Tuma: It’s another great day, as they all are. We’ve had some interesting projects come through: people rebuilding from the Los Angeles fires, people just building retirement homes, vacation homes, so it’s always exciting.

Host: Never a dull moment at Landmark.

Steve Tuma: No, it’s a lot of fun.

Host: So today, I thought we’d get into very general questions that seem to be on the minds of potential panelized home owner-builders these days. So if you’re all set, let’s go ahead and get on with it.

Steve Tuma: Yeah, let’s do it!

Host: And the first round out of the chamber, as it were, is: Open wall panels versus SIPs. Which is better for your home, and explain exactly what both open wall panels and SIPs are.

Steve Tuma: Well, the Landmark Home and Land Company panelized homes are open wall panels just like conventional stick building. So they’re 2x6s, 16 inches on center, with 7/16 OSB on them, headers installed, top and bottom plates are all there. So it’s just like a conventional stick-built home. Where closed panels, generally people use the SIPs, it’s structurally insulated panel. It’s like a piece of OSB, some foam, and then another piece of OSB to make a wall panel. And they claim to have some energy efficiency characteristics which can be good, but it’s also something that needs different engineering. It’s not as typical, it’s probably harder to find crews just because it’s not as generally accepted.

The open panels that Landmark Home and Land Company supplies are very conventional framing; any framer could put them together, building departments understand them, and we can develop complete customized homes with them. So it’s kind of more of a standard, it’s typical, it’s understood. So it just makes it more affordable and easier for people to build their home, and understand the project, and work with the building department, and find contractors. So you don’t need any special tools or any special equipment to work with our stick-built panelized systems. It’s pretty cool.

Host: What I like about talking to you, Steve, is you’re always able to put everything in such a concise and easy to understand—I always want to tell you, “Talk to me like I’m a third grader!” But you don’t talk down; you’re just able to explain the processes, which is, to the average layman like myself, sometimes these questions can be difficult.

Steve Tuma: Well, the situation with this is we’re kind of just a good company wanting to help people. We’re not trying to create any weird image or smoke-and-mirrors game in this; that’s basically what it is. So we like to communicate directly with our customers so they understand what it is. Some customers have never built, some customers have built a lot of homes, and there’s a lot of people in between. So it’s just the way we think and operate: Just kind of keep it simple. Make it so that everyone in the project understands what’s going on. That’s the customer, the contractors, us, the building department inspectors, other material suppliers. So we just want to have fun and help people build cool homes. Kind of keep it simple. There’s a lot of details in designing and building a home, but there’s no reason to complicate it.

Host: Right. It’s complicated enough without somebody explaining to you over your head as well, so pretty appreciated. Now, let’s go on to something really off the wall here—not an off-the-wall question, but just so completely different from the last question you just answered. Let’s talk about delivery day when your home has been put together and it comes on a flatbed. How are the panels unloaded? How are they staged, protected from the weather? Just when they come that first day, how is everything set up?

Steve Tuma: Well, we deliver the panels and trusses on flatbed trucks, just like the typical trucks you see on the highway every day. They’re stacked together; the panels are stacked like pancakes in bundles of, say, six to ten walls. Trusses are banded together in a very similar way. So that’s how it’s put together. We deliver them in the sequence that the customer needs them. Some customers want everything right away; other customers want things delivered in stages.

So if you’re on a smaller city lot, you don’t have as much space, so you might say, “Hey, bring loose materials in, bring walls, bring roof systems in.” If you have more space, you might say, “Hey, bring it all,” and then the contractors can—everything’s right there. So the key to it is we will work with customers on delivering and staging the materials as they need it, so it’s advantageous to make it easy for the framers to assemble the home package on-site.

You ask about weather, and that’s an interesting thing. What we do is we work with customers to make sure that the delivery is made when they need it. Okay, so we’d rather not have materials sitting in our yard or materials sitting at their building site. We like to have it where the foundation contractor finishes the foundation, everything’s backfilled, ready, they leave, and then our trucks show up and the framers literally pick the materials up and start framing.

So it’s a situation that we’re able to schedule the deliveries according to what their framing contractor needs, so that the materials aren’t sitting around. Weird things happen when anything sits around. So it’s good just to have it where the truck shows up, the guys unload it, and then they start framing. So the weather issue gets to be limited on something like that. The reality is none of us have figured out how to control rain or different situations, but it’s pretty rare that rain creates a big issue. We found that by coordinating the deliveries, we’re able to help move the project along, make it easier for the framer, make it easier for the customer, and end up with a high-quality product.

Host: So you guys, the best-case scenario and what you strive for, is to make sure the time between when a truss comes off the truck and it’s being lifted up is as short as possible, right?

Steve Tuma: Right. That’s the idea, is we want to deliver them, the framing crew unloads them, and then they start placing them on the walls. That’s what you want. It’s just when stuff sits around, it’s a bigger chance for weather, it’s a bigger chance of on-site damage or whatever. And the reality is everyone wants the project to move along. So by our ability to communicate, our desire to communicate, our desire to be extremely customer-service-oriented, we’re able to work with a customer to make sure materials show up when they need it, so that their framing crew can move along, and they get the house framed up and get it done. It’s a lot of coordination, communication, and just keeping on top of it, but that’s what we do every day. That’s how we support our customers and make it easy on them.

Host: Right. Here’s a question that in different variations, different forms has come across my desk a few times, but I think it’s really important to go over it because it’s something that not only helps a builder have a great experience building, but it also builds confidence. So my question would be: Which parts of the build can I—and I mean realistically—do myself to save money, and which should I always hire out?

Steve Tuma: What I tell customers is only do work that you know you can do, okay? So don’t go watching a YouTube video on framing, or running electric, or things like that. Just if you’re in the trades and you know how to install a foundation, or know how to frame, or you understand things, I would say do that. If you’re not sure, I think it’s better to hire something out.

Now, someone might say, “Hey, painting you don’t have to necessarily have a high skill.” I’m like, well, a professional painter does understand the paint, the brushes, the method of doing it. But yeah, some stuff like that you might be able to slide by with, but there is an art and a craft to this, and you do want to build a quality home.

This brings up an interesting situation, because this is actually tied into the budgeting. Because a lot of times people will be budgeting, they’re like, “Oh, Steve, I’m going to do this,” or “My Uncle Joe’s going to show up,” or “Uncle Fred’s going to show up.” I’m like, “Are you sure they’re going to?” Because you don’t want to convince yourself in the budgeting stage that all your friends are going to come out of the woodwork and take their summer or winter to build your house. I mean, some people have those connections or family roots where they can do it, but don’t convince yourself of doing work that you can’t do. Because as you go through the process, you’re going to end up in a situation.

So my opinion is be honest with yourself. If you know how to do drywall, do it. If you know how to run electric, do it. But if you don’t, don’t do it. So what a lot of our customers do is they coordinate people that are professionals in each discipline, and then they’ll do the work themselves. Sometimes they get a contractor that gets some people for them and then they get others. So there’s a lot of different ways to get the different help and trades together to get someone’s project moving along.

Host: Yeah, it sounds like those pharmaceutical commercials: “Don’t take such and such if you’re allergic to it.”

Steve Tuma: Well, yeah, the difference is we’re being honest about it! Some of those things, they’re so happy to tell you that you might die. But in our situation, we’d rather be just straight out and say, “Hey, if you don’t know how to do drywall, don’t do it.” Drywall’s the perfect example. I mean, you look at it, it’s like, “How hard is it going to be to nail sheetrock up there? How hard is it to mud it?” Well, it’s one of those skills that there’s actually a lot of skill involved with a lot of the trades, and even though you might watch a YouTube video or someone says, “Oh, yeah, I did it in my sleep,” it’s a little different. And you want it done right.

The reason I kind of speak very directly about this and other parts of building the home is you don’t want customers that get misled or mislead themselves into biting off more than they can chew. Because if you put drywall up and it’s not done right, the cost of fixing it’s bigger. So you’re better off being honest with yourself and saying, “Hey, I can do this work, it’s better to hire someone else out.” And we’re more than willing to talk to customers about the ins and outs of this if they just need to get a handle of, “Hey, who do I get here? How do I get this? What’s the schedule?” We can work with the customers on that. We’re here to help customers.

Host: Right. Okay, so now I, Mr. Owner-Builder, have decided that I can’t do everything, and I need to go out and find some subcontractors. How do I find them? How do I vet them? How do I schedule them when I’ve never built a house before?

Steve Tuma: Well, the interesting thing that you can do is basically sometimes if you find one contractor, they’ll lead you to another contractor. So for example, an excavation contractor typically always knows foundation guys. Foundation guys always seem to know framers and roofers and things like that. Plumbing, electric, and heat guys all seem to work together.

So I would say the thing to do is work—you can go through different online services. Sometimes you can go to building departments and say, “Hey, who’s licensed in my area?” The building department may not tell you, “Hey, Joe’s XYZ Contractors is the best,” but you might be able to say, “Hey, who do you see in here a lot?” or “Who asks the best questions?” or something like that.

You can always look at reviews, and in some states there’s licensing portals online where you can go check to see if there’s issues. But a lot of the better contractors, they actually don’t advertise; it’s kind of through the network. So sometimes, like if you’re working with a roofing supply house, they may have a list of roofers that are good.

And what’s amazing is the customers that work well and understand working with the subcontractors, they always do simple things like: Does the person call on time? Do they do what they say? Are they complete in what they’re telling you? And the basic gut-feeling meter. That’s how it is.

So the key to what we do with our plan set is we have a very clear and accurate set of plans. So if you go to a contractor and say, “Hey, I need windows for this house,” or “I need roof shingles,” “I need framing done,” “I need mechanical systems done,” with a good set of plans that we supply, they’ll take you more seriously. You can’t go there with a standard set of plans or some hand sketch on a napkin and say, “Hey, how much is a 2,000-square-foot house?” A lot of people will do that to people in the building trades, and then they’ll wonder why the contractor doesn’t take them seriously.

And I jokingly tell them, I’m like, “Okay, so you go call a guy and say, ‘Hey, how much is it to build a 3,000-square-foot home?’ That’s a preliminary question, but then I’ll ask the same person and say, ‘When’s the last time you called the grocery store and said how much is dinner?'”

Host: Right! It’s kind of funny; it’s kind of the same thing, right?

Steve Tuma: Yeah, so that’s why we kind of say, “Hey, get a plan, know what you’re building, get a schedule, tell them you’re financed, you’re ready to go, you have the money, your intent on building in this schedule.” They’ll take you seriously, and you’ll find that you’ll get a better reaction.

Now, a lot of these guys are very busy; they may tell you they’ll get you a quote in three days, and it may show up in two weeks. Sometimes that’s the nature of building just because they’re out there doing their job. They don’t make money on quotes; they make money building houses. Which is why I say it’s important to have a complete and accurate set of plans, tell them what your intentions are, tell them the money availability, and tell them the schedule, and you put yourself in a better position for them to take you seriously.

It’s a two-way street. A lot of customers think, “Hey, I’m the guy with the money, the contractor should listen to me.” Well, the contractors have a little bit of pull there because they’re busy, and the skilled labor is limited, so they want to know they’re working with a good potential customer as well.

Host: Sure. And you’ve talked about this before: The well-informed owner-builder, the one who’s done their research, is the one that’s going to end up saving time and money in the end.

Steve Tuma: Oh, yeah, you’ve got to pay attention, and we will do everything we can to help a customer understand their project, and also develop a set of plans that puts them in a position to represent that project to the building departments, banks, homeowners associations, historic committees, and the contractors.

Host: Walk in prepared, people!

Steve Tuma: That’s basically it. Sometimes people do that, they’re like, “Well, I called this guy and said, ‘How much is it to paint a 2,000-square-foot home?'” I’m like, “Hey, look in your own world, whatever job you do. If you’re an Uber driver, if you’re a grocery store person, if you work in a restaurant, if you’re an executive, and someone asks you such a broad-ended question that there’s no way to accurately answer it, you wonder if that person asking the question is serious.”

Host: Yeah, Uber drivers is a great example: “How much does it cost to go from Illinois to California?”

Steve Tuma: Yeah, I don’t know! So that’s the thing, and that’s what we do with customers, is work with them so they understand their project. And a lot of our customers automatically want to know that, because they’re choosing to build the home as a life experience; it’s a new chapter in their family’s next step in life. It’s pretty amazing. I don’t want to make it sound so complex, though; it’s something where step-by-step we work with customers and help each customer for the information that they need. And sometimes there’s follow-up questions of which we’re available to help them, and that’s the key: We have great customer support, and we enjoy helping putting customers in better positions, because then they just get a better house.

Host: Yeah. Let’s talk about the competition a little bit—not really, but indirectly. People want to know: What’s the best way to compare quotes from different kit and panelized home companies fairly? And you probably deal with this a lot talking to customers who ask you about another company and why are they a little cheaper or why are they more expensive.

Steve Tuma: Well, that’s a very good question, because what a lot of people do is they just look at the price. So someone says, “Hey, here’s Company A is this price, Company B is this price, Company C is this price.” And what they don’t realize is it’s not the bottom-line dollar, it’s what’s included that’s a very important part of making that decision.

So we had that situation come up where a customer was online, just the way they found us. They asked us how much the wood package was for it, and we gave them a price, and then they said, “Well, this other company was like a quarter of the price.” And I’m sitting here going, “That’s not possible; they’re not supplying the right things.” So they were gracious enough to send us the bid.

Well, they were just supplying parts of the walls, the exterior walls. They weren’t doing interior, they weren’t doing floor systems, they weren’t doing roof systems, they weren’t doing sheathing, they weren’t doing beams, they weren’t doing plans, they weren’t doing all the details necessary to help you get a permit.

So what was nice about that customer is they realized that there was an issue, and they trusted us to go through and review it. So what people have to understand is not all plans are the same, and not all panel packages are the same. Because it’s a relatively complex process of understanding plans, engineering, permitting, energy codes, you can’t assume that all panels are the same.

So it’s not like a gallon of milk where you could pretty much say a gallon of milk from Dairy A is the same as Dairy B. These are completely different. So: How are they nailed? What’s the sheathing? What are the headers? How are the second plates put on? How do you know that beams fit in the structure? How do you know it matches the engineering? How do you know that the structure and architectural design work with your energy calculations?

And that’s one of the things that’s very hard for a customer to understand. There’s a lot of variables unless you really understand it’s not there. But as far as I know, we’re the only company that really works to give a guaranteed price for the design that the customer wants, to put all those details together. It’s a guaranteed price to get that taken care of, and we don’t raise prices on people just because. We don’t nickel-dime, lowball, and then raise the price. We go through and give our quote—it’s one that when they sign the contract, it is locked in.

And that’s the key, and it details that we’re doing the energy calculations, we’re doing the site plan, we’re doing the structural engineering, what we’re including for beams, what we’re including for walls, what we’re including for sheathing, top plates, different details like that. So it comes together as a unified package. Instead of working with individual people and hoping the project comes together, with us, we’re that classic one-stop shop where we can tell you the cost up front, keep to that cost, and then help you design the home that works for you.

Sometimes it’s kind of like breaking little pieces up, thinking that 1 + 1 + 1 = 3. Well, that may make sense, but there’s always unknowns, there’s always like: How do you know that that’s the right element to go into it? And what’s the most interesting thing to me is people will say, “Well, I went over here, and they gave me a quote, and they’ve been in business for however long.” It’s like, great, did they pay attention?

Because some of these quotes that people send over when they’re kind of reviewing us versus them, it’s amazing that I’ve never gotten one that was complete. So there’s a certain game in lumber pricing where they just give a lowball price to be the lower side of it, but they’re not breaking out and telling you that the materials are right, that they’ve been engineered, that it makes sense for your project, that beams are sized right, and all those details. So it’s very easy for someone to get caught in something, where we go through and give a guaranteed price for the exact house that you want to build. So it’s wrapping up all those loose ends that customers don’t understand.

And that’s a very important part of what Landmark Home and Land Company supplies, is the complete set of plans, engineering, permitting plan set, and the panelized home package that matches. It’s an extreme benefit to customers to know up front the price that they want to pay for the home package so that they could properly budget and schedule their home.

Host: Right. I know it probably changes from job to job, or there are variables and everything, but how long does that process take? I mean, the actual for you to put a bid together that you know is solid and will help the customer as well—is that a long process?

Steve Tuma: People email us a plan, or they’ll pick a plan off our website, or they’ll sketch it on a napkin and text it to us, and we can go through and get them a price in a day or two.

Host: Whoa!

Steve Tuma: Go through and—well, we’ve got pricing models from 33 years; we understand it. We understand how a home is going to be put together. We understand the different building departments. We understand the different materials for different parts of the country. So that’s what we’re able to do, is get to a customer, and then if they want to review it, we’re here to talk to them about the details and how we go through.

But again, a lot of people will call and say, “Hey, I want a panelized home.” Well, we’re doing a lot more than that. We’re supplying the plans, the engineering, all the details, all the customer support to help through the process. So we’re extremely competitive even when compared to raw materials, while we supply all the details to help them through the process of designing the home, and getting permits, and getting the home package delivered.

Now, what’s interesting is just this week, we got two reviews of people saying that the customer support, all the details, the help, the design elements were things that they never even realized were important. Until they were in the phases of designing and building, they never realized it. So that’s what we’re trying to tell people is, “Hey, this isn’t just buy a stack of wood and it magically goes together. This is a, ‘Hey, let’s look at your project and get you taken care of properly.'”

So that’s the element that we try to point out to people: This isn’t buying a gallon of milk. This is getting the help, the design, making sure it’s designed right to be cost-effective for getting permits quickly, but also assembling the home package and finishing the building processes of finishing the home.

Host: Well, once again, another informative edition of the podcast. I always learn so much from these things, just sitting here with the microphone in my face and listening to you. It’s always informative. It’s so much fun to do this podcast with you because there’s so much to learn, and you’re really good at explaining things in such a way that, like I said, the layman like myself actually can understand it.

Steve Tuma: Well, that’s part of what we supply. So someone goes through and they watch some show, or they read a book or whatever, but it’s like: How does this apply to me? So there’s some guy on YouTube or some TV show saying, “This is how you build a house.” It’s like, okay, they’re over there on a flat piece of land; you’re over here on the side of a hill, in an earthquake zone, or the other way around. So that’s what we do, is we have the understanding and real-life experience and the projects like that to help people through. That’s the key element that people I think find very valuable, and they don’t really realize it until they’re already working with us.

Host: Right. Well, that’s going to just about wrap it up for today’s edition of the Panelized Prefab Kit Home Building Show. But before we let you scoot out of here, Steve, like we always do, let the listeners know how to find out more about Landmark Home and Land Company.

Steve Tuma: Well, the best thing to do is check out our website at LHLC.com, kind of like the initials Landmark Home Land Company. On our website, there’s these podcasts, there’s videos, there’s details on what we supply in different conversations, customer reviews, a lot of details. And what people generally do is they’ll send us a direct email from the web page, or they can find a plan they like and click on there and send us a message asking about a plan, or they can just give us a call at 800-830-9788. And Mike will answer the phone and get a conversation going.

We are very proactive in answering the phone. If by chance you get a voicemail, leave a message; we will call you back right away. And Mike will work with customers up front, and at a certain stage they start working with me when they want to get plans going and kind of get into the details.

But if someone had a question they want to talk to me specifically, they can always give me a call on my direct cell at 708-205-2043. And we’ll take the time. We want to know our customers, we want to know what they’re up to, what it is they want to gain out of this house, why they’re doing it, what their priorities are. It’s a lot of fun, it’s incredible. We’ve been doing it 33 years, and every house project is still extremely exciting.

Host: And there you go! Thanks, Steve. Thanks to all of you for listening to the Panelized Prefab Kit Home Building Show. So for Landmark Home and Land Company President Steve Tuma and myself, have a great week, and we will see you next time. Thanks again, Steve.

Steve Tuma: Thank you.

About Landmark Design Team